The importance of a pure devotee’s association.
Student: Maharaj, I once heard that the chanting of Hare Krishna and Srimad Bhagavatam must be taken together, that the chanting of Hare Krishna alone will have some effect but the knowledge within Srimad Bhagavatam must also be there.
Srila Sridhar Maharaj: Not only Bhagavatam. That presupposes Bhakta Bhagavatam also. Sadhu-sanga and Nam-kirtan, these are the best. When there is want of sadhu-sanga, want of living scripture, then there is passive scripture [Bhagavatam].
sadhu-sange krsna-nama ei matra chai
(Sri Sri Prema-vivarta: 6.13)
With the association of the sadhu, we want to chant the Lord’s Name, and when the sadhu is not available, then of course with scripture, sastra.
We are to take men to the guidance of the sadhu, the man of higher realisation. There may be so many obstacles, appositions, and difficulties along the way, but with his help, they may be removed. So, the guidance of the sadhu has been advised to be indispensable. But when sadhu is not available, then sastra comes. Mahaprabhu says:
sadhu-sanga, nama-kirtana, bhagavata-sravana
mathura-vasa, sri-murtira sraddhaya sevana
sakala-sadhana-srestha ei panca anga
[“(1) Associating with sadhus. (2) Chanting the Lords’ Name. (3) Hearing the scriptures of pure devotion. (4) Residing in a holy place. (5) Faithfully serving the Lord’s Deity. These five are the best of all the limbs of devotional practice.”]
And if only one is to be accepted, then it is Nam-kirtan. Kirtan means to chant loudly, and that presupposes that with the company of someone or in congregation we will chant. So, sankirtan. Srila Jiva Goswami Prabhu has given this interpretation of sankirtan:
bahubhir militva yat kirtanam tad eva sankirtanam
To talk about Krishna not alone but in a group is sankirtan. But Srila Bhakti Vinod Thakur also warns: “Don’t join any type of imitation sankirtan. At least one leading man must be there who is a suddha bhakta [pure devotee]. When there is cholera or the great epidemic, some people want to go on with Nam-sankirtan, but that is aparadha [offensive]. They want the Name, the Lord, Hari, to remove all inauspicious things from the world. That is sakam [interested] chanting. That is aparadha. A suddha bhakta, a pure devotee, will not associate when such sankirtan is going on. So, at least one pure devotee must be in the group, then one can join the sankirtan.” In this way, Srila Bhaki Vinod Thakur has warned that there must be guidance under a pure devotee, who is nirguna, who does not want anything mundane, but only the grace of Hari. That type of vibration must be present there, and that will help me in my subtle-most plane of self, my nirguna aspect, and awaken me.
Spoken on 30 August 1981.